Author Nordwand Editorial Team Published Updated 8 min read

When judgment gets skewed on a hike: Normalcy bias and pressure to go along

When judgment gets skewed on a hike: Normalcy bias and pressure to go along

“The dark clouds are far off, so we’re fine.” “The people ahead are going, so I’ll follow.” “We’ve come too far to turn back.” Thoughts like these are a reason to check what your decision is based on. Here are four patterns to notice when deciding whether to go on or turn around.

When to reassess on the trail

Expectations and other people’s reactions can shape what information we notice and how we interpret it. Psychology experiments and studies of disasters offer ways to look at decisions we can revisit on a hike.

You are tired, sunset is near or your companions are moving ahead. When you feel short of time to think, stop somewhere stable and check your position, the time, the weather and how everyone is feeling.

Normalcy bias: Treating a change as business as usual

Research on disaster warnings has found that people can interpret information about a new danger as part of a situation they are used to. This can also help you look back at decisions on the trail.

Clouds are building, the ground has become slick or a companion keeps stopping. When you see a change, check what you observe now and the forecast before relying on how things looked last time.

Work backward from the planned descent time to set a time for reaching a junction or turning around. If you hear thunder, find the trail impassable or notice someone’s condition worsening, reassess before the scheduled time.

Peer pressure: “If everyone else is going”

When your assessment differs from those around you, speaking up can be hard. In Solomon Asch’s experiments, participants compared line lengths. Some agreed with the others when the group gave a unanimous answer.

People ahead or your leader may be moving on with different skills, equipment or plans from yours. Watching someone continue tells you little about whether the next section is safe for your group.

Agree before leaving that anyone can ask to stop or go back. When someone is uneasy, stop, ask what change they noticed and then decide.

The sunk cost effect: “We’ve come this far”

Having spent time, money or effort can make us want to keep going. This is called the sunk cost effect. Hal Arkes and Catherine Blumer studied the pattern in experiments.

When you think “I’ve already walked four hours” or “we’ve planned this for months,” check the time and energy you still have. Compare the routes, weather and descent times for continuing, turning back and shortening the trip.

You cannot recover nonrefundable expenses or the time already spent walking. Consider what you still have and which safe options are available now. The summit can go into another day’s plan.

Confirmation bias: “See, we’re fine”

Confirmation bias is the tendency to give more weight to information that fits what you already think and overlook information that goes against it. In Peter Wason’s experiment, some participants tended to choose examples that fit their hypothesis when testing it.

When you really want to go, the sunny forecast may stick in your mind while you miss forecasts or advisories pointing to bad weather. Compare forecasts for the area and times you will be hiking.

Before leaving, ask what would make you stop. If the forecast worsens, you arrive late or someone feels unwell, agree on what to check and how you could shorten the route.

Steps to notice bias

Decide which checks you can make on your next hike and share them with the group.

  1. Set criteria in advance: Work backward from your planned return to set a time to reach a junction or turn back.
  2. Check what is different: Describe what has changed in the weather, footing, physical condition or equipment.
  3. Ask for another view: Ask everyone what they noticed or what worries them, including people behind the leader.
  4. Say what feels off: Give an observation, such as “the wind has picked up” or “we are 20 minutes late.”
  5. Review a turnaround decision: After coming down, record which information helped you decide.

The psychology research here does not measure how often these factors contribute to mountain incidents. On the trail, consider the time, terrain, weather, everyone’s condition and equipment together.

Summary

Normalcy bias, peer pressure, the sunk cost effect and confirmation bias give you ways to examine your own judgment on the trail. Before going on, revisit your criteria and check what has changed and what companions have noticed.

Before your next hike, share one condition for turning back and pick a place to ask, “What has changed since we started?”

References and sources

Find your mountain community

Find hiking partners and join communities. Plan your next adventure with Nordwand.