Old Baldy and the Sierra Blanca Massif
Before receiving its current name, the peak was known as Old Baldy, a designation associated in historical accounts with its exposed upper slopes. It stands within the Sierra Blanca massif, a grouping that includes Blanca Peak and forms one of the prominent summit clusters in the southern Sangre de Cristo Mountains. The Huerfano drainage borders the peak to the north, connecting its high terrain to the broader river system below.
Survey Expeditions of 1875
Colorado Mountain Club material preserved in the Montana State University archive records two distinct survey parties taking note of the peak during 1875. Personnel with the Hayden Survey noted Old Baldy during a June outing to Blanca, while the Wheeler Survey made a recorded ascent later that same year. These are separate expeditions representing different federal survey programs, and the archive's language of recorded ascent is the appropriate qualifier for the Wheeler party's climb.
Malcolm Lindsey and the Renaming
Malcolm Lindsey joined the Colorado Mountain Club in 1922 and led younger members on outings to Old Baldy, building a personal association with the peak over the following years. Following his death the club proposed that the mountain bear his name. The U.S. Board on Geographic Names issued its decision on July 30, 1953, and a formal dedication followed in 1954 — two distinct steps in the official record marking the transition to its recognized name.