A Name from the 1895 Solomons Exploration
Ernest Bonner proposed the name during his 1895 exploration with Theodore Solomons, honoring Eugene Woldemar Hilgard, soil scientist, geologist, and founding director of the California Agricultural Experiment Station. Francis Farquhar noted that the original 1897 description accompanying the name may in fact refer to what is now identified as the separate summit called Recess Peak, and that historical ambiguity has not been fully resolved.
USGS Triangulation and the Summit Points
The USGS triangulation report describes three small summit points on Mount Hilgard and specifies which of them the survey team used for its measurements. That triangulation record documents a measured station on the peak; it does not establish whether the surveyors were the first people to reach the top.
Farquhar's 1905 Ascent Record
Farquhar records a July 1905 ascent by surveyor Charles F. Urquhart, the earliest climbing account attached to the peak in the Sierra Club historical literature. The summit lies above the Bear Creek and Mono Creek high country, within the broader central Sierra terrain covered by the Mount Hilgard USGS quadrangle.